I've always heard that you shouldn't start a rookie QB in the NFL. You should groom them behind a veteran. Isn't that what AR did? It seems as if just because Favre came out of retirement, AR is all of a sudden a rookie that sucks. Jesus, if you never moved on to a new QB, Bart would still be there. How much experience did BF have when Majik went down? It's ridiculous.

I remember the same comments about Carson Palmer and that he was dumb(Big Blue Cane). It takes awhile to find out about QB's.

I want to know from the people who thinks Favre should have been awarded his job back:

Would you trade Rodgers for...

a) Kitna

b) Orton/Grossman

c) Jackson


You know what? AR might be the best out of the bunch. We'll soon find out, but I'll keep what we have, thank you.

I think it depends on the QB and the team and the market. If there's a team with a bunch of grumpy old vets on offense it makes it a little harder.

I think Rodgers is in a great position to succeed. TT has built a high character team as evidence by not a single player leaking any significant dissent with everything that's happened. I think DD realized how important his role is in that.

I think Favre's aloofness and distance from the younger players made it easier for them to turn young.

Thanks for a well thought out reply Tit. (I've always wanted to say that...)

quote:

Originally posted by antiworst:
I want to know from the people who thinks Favre should have been awarded his job back:

Would you trade Rodgers for...

a) Kitna

b) Orton/Grossman

c) Jackson


You know what? AR might be the best out of the bunch. We'll soon find out, but I'll keep what we have, thank you.

I wouldn't trade him for any of them. I think Favre is better than Rodgers, but I also think Rodgers is better than that group.

Well then Jihad...we're going to the playoffs!!!!

I read "Here's what I don't get..." then I looked at antiworsts avatar again.

quote:

Originally posted by justanotherpackerfan:
I read "Here's what I don't get..." then I looked at antiworsts avatar again.

Guys, they're JUST boobs...okay...forget I ever said that...

quote:

Originally posted by antiworst:
Well then Jihad...we're going to the playoffs!!!!

I tend to agree.

Same type people howled when Mike McCarthy was hired. No experience as head coach. Not a good OC in SF etc etc

It's certainly to ARod's benefit that he's had a few years to learn as a backup. Sure it's going to take him some time to apply and perfect what he has learned come game time, but what better replacement situation could fans ask for?

Huh?? what??
Opps sorry guys, just a little daydreaming going on.